Channels
Log in register
piqd uses cookies and other analytical tools to offer this service and to enhance your user experience.

Your podcast discovery platform

Curious minds select the most fascinating podcasts from around the world. Discover hand-piqd audio recommendations on your favorite topics.

You are currently in channel:

Boom and bust

Christian Odendahl
Econpiqster
View piqer profile
piqer: Christian Odendahl
Monday, 13 March 2017

Gender Quotas Vs Meritocracy

I was waiting for a "research digest" of this great economic research paper, and now it has arrived. The idea is to study the impact of a gender quota on the competence of political leaders. That is no easy task: quotas are not introduced randomly, which means that studying the effect is difficult; and measuring competence is not easy (most use "education", but that is clearly just a proxy). 

Enter Sweden, where data is available on almost everyone and everything, and the social democrats introduced a strict quota on how they set up party lists. The results?

Mediocre leaders have a strong incentive to surround themselves with mediocre followers, so as to bolster their chances of remaining in power. A less acknowledged role of quotas is to create a threat to such cozy arrangements. It is this idea that our research on Sweden has investigated. Our main finding is that gender quotas increase the competence of the political class in general, and among men in particular. Moreover, quotas are indeed bad news for mediocre male leaders who tend to be forced out.

It is a well-written explainer of a complicated (you cannot study these things by simple means) research paper. 

(Full disclosure: I did my PhD at Stockholm University and know the authors.)

Gender Quotas Vs Meritocracy
8.8
6 votes
relevant?

Would you like to comment? Then register now for free!

Comments 3
  1. Elvia Wilk
    Elvia Wilk · Created about 2 years ago ·

    So glad this study was done! This data will be useful for the next dinner-party disagreement on "meritocracy"...

    1. Christian Odendahl
      Christian Odendahl · Created about 2 years ago ·

      Oh yes, I agree. Though in my experience, the data only gets me half-way when trying to convince people who are principally opposed. As a famous economist once said: it takes a theory to beat a theory. So the mechanism that they explore I think is helpful for my next dinner party chat, too: breaking the network of mediocre people.

    2. Elvia Wilk
      Elvia Wilk · Created about 2 years ago ·

      @Christian Odendahl True: data sadly does not convince (thinking of: https://www.piqd.com/h...)... but it does help me feel more sane when I have a study to point to!

Stay up to date – with a newsletter from your channel on Boom and bust.